Previously written is this observation about the City, Band Report and now the charge that Columbia County Directory is putting out false facts by The Police Association. For the full account scroll down to the bold date 1/25/2026 and read the account. We also recieved a very insightful transcript that contains what we believe to be prudent in our city for the police situation and lack of funding.
Our city on the river is in a turbulent situation – Police Department Updates and Water Bills on the Rise. Regarding Police – From the horses mouth – no additions or corrections without notation of such – For those who have been asking about the police overages of revealed at city council sessions on Wednesday January 2026 is the budgeted for the year is 300,000. However based on current and projection we will be at $543,000 for the budget year. We have not negotiated the next Police Union raise which is on the docket. Was this the raise whether one gets approved or not? Why did no one know this or report this was happening?
Some background info and a deepdive in the Jim Band Report on our police compared to the entire industry standards. His conclusion was as follows:
Report states: “Chief Greenway pushed his officers into an oversimplistic
view of the budget and seemed to have convinced them they were somehow being wronged.
In the case of St. Helens, it has led to some officers thinking they are not being supported by the City, while at the same time the City has put tremendous investment into the police department. This being the approximate 15% pay raise and $10 utility fee for the new building. Any department would have been very happy to have one of these investments by their City. In this case, in spite of these investments, Chief Greenway seems to have convinced everyone they were not supported. In May of 2024, voters voted no by a voting margin of 15% against a local option levy to add four police positions to the budget. This demonstrates that elected officials were willing to put the levy on the ballot. In this case, the voters made a fairly strong statement that they did not support additional tax revenue for the police. It is unclear what Chief Greenway or the union thought Mayor Scholl or City Administrator Walsh were to have done to come up with additional revenue. Their perspective seems unrealistic. General fund revenue comes from taxes—the voters said no. A look at the City budget shows that the support of the police has grown over recent years. In 2018, the Police Department budget was 34% of the appropriated general fund budget. In 2024, the Police Department budget was 40% of the appropriated general fund budget, a significant increase. The police department has also increased their number of officers in that time. The police department had 17 sworn officers in 2018, and they have 24 sworn officers at this time in 2025. That is a current officer per thousand ratio of 1.67. This ratio does not tell a complete story of the needs of a community, but anecdotally it is on the high side of agencies in Oregon. Here is a random comparison of officer per thousand ratios of a few random cities in Oregon:
Albany Police Department: 1.14
Grants Pass Police Department: 1.41
Oregon City Police Department: 1.22
Tigard Police Department: 1.38
St. Helens Police Department: 1.67
CONFIDENTIAL Page 106 Band Report
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Page 107 continues here.
I do not understand how the perception that the police department was underfunded exists. Shift coverage might be difficult with the current openings, but the chosen shift hours utilized by the department are also problematic. 10-hour shift schedules are great for employees, who enjoy a four day work week with three day weekends, but they are unequivocally the most difficult way to staff a police department. This is basically because 24 hours are not divisible by 10. This analysis of staffing matters because I have been unable to support the theories put forth in the no confidence vote and by Chief Greenway that the City was or is understaffed. My perspective is that there are two issues related to staffing within the police department.
The first is filling open positions. It is the police chief’s responsibility to build a culture that will draw the best candidates. While St. Helens PD has great comparative pay, Chief Greenway’s described bombastic nature does not appear to have built such a culture. Chief Greenway’s disdain for working with other police agencies would likely keep many local lateral candidates from applying—this strange stance was known regionally, and it was seen as a negative.
The second is the shift schedule. From the perspective of employees, a ten-hour shift is great because it provides manageable work hours and three-day weekends. The downside of these schedules is that they are easily the most difficult to fill. There are several examples of departments going off of ten-hour shifts to eight or twelve hour shifts when positions are lost or in emergencies. The point here is that Chief Greenway seems to have worked up the union and members of the public with misguided information. The City of St. Helens seems to have strong support for their police department. Chief Greenway, with the help of the union executive board, seem to have taken advantage of that support. Some members of the public seem to have taken them at their word, though the evidence shows the department is not underfunded at all.
His evaluation continues to reveal even more about what others including the police were willing to do to get rid of John Walsh and Rick Scholl. https://www.opb.org/…/St%20Helens%20Greenway%20Report… for the full report – final pages give entire opinion by expert.
1/25/2026 Police Association Comment on above post. *********
Columbia County Directory comment: Officers have left – or got fired. However; you had a chief of police actively engaged in turning qualified candidates away – see inside report confirming his actions. One officer that left is obviously Joe Hogue and now Matt Smith who suggested he may return to a detective position – and was appointed Chief just recently.
St. Helens Police Association Commented on this post on our fb site.
There are currently 7 sworn Officers, 4 Sergeants, 1 Lieutenant and 1 Chief. That is a total of 13 sworn. We are attempting to hire and train 5. If all 5 complete training, we will still be understaffed, but will be capable of going back to 24 hour coverage with a reduction in overtime costs.
Please know the facts before making misleading posts.
Columbia County Directory replied: Are you saying that the Band Report was inaccurate? This is straight from the expert investigation into Greenway. Why has no one called that out as false and corrected it? Or, is it that this was accurate on the time and day he wrote it?
- Reply from St. Helens Police Association
Columbia County Directory we don’t even have enough mailboxes at the Police Department for that many sworn positions. We did not have 25 at the time of the Band report. If that is stated in the report, then the report is inaccurate.
Columbia County Directory replied
This is what is written. I would think that if this information was incorrect it would certainly be corrected at least. I got my facts from an official paid report by the City of St. Helens. It looks like you may be referencing something else and are confused. I don’t see why you are referencing 25 officers. Jim Band said as shown above: “The police department had 17 sworn officers in 2018, and they have 24 sworn officers at this time in 2025. That is a current officer per thousand ratio of 1.67. This ratio does not tell a complete story of the needs of a community, but anecdotally it is on the high side of agencies in Oregon.” Jim Band. I’m happy you are involved in this conversation because clearly there is some very basic information you are calling me out on. If the facts as stated are incorrect and no one takes the time in almost a year since the report to correct it then it points to another reason why it wouldn’t be corrected – again – because the Mayor and whoever the Chief of Police really is can’t be bothered to make a very important correction that would matter to the people who paid for the report.
St. Helens Police Association replied
Columbia County Directory correction, stated 25, was meant to say 24, which is what you wrote in this post. We did not have 24 sworn, that is incorrect.
Columbia County Directory we do not speak for the Mayor or the Chief of Police, neither of whom were in their positions at the time the Band investigation was done. We speak merely as the Association.
Columbia County Directory replied St. Helens Police Association You might want to have that corrected so we don’t have bad information. You ask that we get our facts straight when we are quoting yours. How do we do this when the city publishes bad information and no one bothers to correct it? Are we to believe that no one read or fact checked that report or that no one actually cares? At this time I believe either or both could be true.
Can you at least tell us who the real chief is? I believe it to be Matt Smith but it seems like Jennifer Massey is giving out reams of information on all types of police policy, protocols, pages upon pages. Is anyone fact checking that? I am sure you can understand why there is so much confusion. This little piece of calling us out to state facts is such a great example of why we are where we are. Thank you so much for answering. We do not want to give out bad information. So will you be having the report corrected? That particular piece is very important since you want more officers and let a report go out with false information in it. Or who provided Jim Band with this information? Maybe we should request that document.
Columbia County Directory asked these questions as well.
And the next question will be why did you officers say nothing when your chief of police was openly trying to squelch any hiring to make them “pay” for the lack of preceived support? It sure worked didn’t it?
Columbia County Directory With all that is being speculated on why in the world would the council, police officers, Chiefs and even Massey who seems to have taken over the role of spokeperson for the police not demanded a correction in that report? I don’t get it.
Community Comments & Suggestions Which Massey Asked for at prior council meeting. We felt this deserved some attention and possibly will be addressed at a future council meeting. The below was submitted for publication here.
Watching the sudden appearance of St. Helens Police in the news again, promoted by the City Mayor Massey and the Chief/ Detective/Sergeant Smith, I’ve decided to weigh in and ask some questions. I will start by saying this; I appreciate the work our police officers do.
Nothing in this post is about interfering with investigations or criticizing the police for doing their work. In fact, that is exactly why I am saying this. These are serious matters, and they deserve to be handled with professionalism, restraint, and data, not politics and not emotional pressure. Budgets should not be set based on fear. Policy should not be driven by narrative framing. And the mayor, because of her direct conflict of interest, should recuse herself from shaping or promoting these discussions. The council, city, citizens should be asking her to recuse herself.
What I believe we need to be asking for, and what the public should always ask for, is context, comparisons, and clear data. That is responsible governance.
Let me ground this in how government is actually supposed to work:
City resources are for city needs first. Listening to the council work session, I was left with more questions than answers. If St. Helens police resources, overtime budget, or specialized lab capacity are being heavily used for regional cases, referrals, or outside agency work, the public is entitled to know:
How much work is local versus outside our jurisdiction?
How much overtime is being driven by non-St. Helens cases?
Are local taxpayers subsidizing work that benefits other jurisdictions?
“We need more money” depends on what work is being done. If overtime is high because the department chose to take on more external work, expanded its scope after building new capacity, or because the Chief is doing line-investigator work instead of executive management, then that is a management and prioritization question, not automatically a funding problem.
I think it is fair to ask some basic management questions:
Why is our Police Chief functioning as both Chief and lead detective?
If he is as overworked as claimed, why did he not defer the position to then Acting Chief Hogue, who was already doing the job?
How much of the Chief’s time is spent on administration and management versus hands-on investigations?
If the department is stretched and over budget, is that the most efficient use of executive-level time?
Police authority has limits. Law enforcement authority exists to investigate crimes or determine whether a crime occurred. It does not exist to investigate “ethical issues,” conduct employment or professional discipline fishing expeditions, or pursue quasi administrative investigations that belong to other bodies.
Is significant department time is being spent on matters that never meet the threshold of criminal investigation?
If so that is a serious governance issue. It represents a misuse of police authority and public money.
Now let’s look at the data we do have:
According to the St. Helens Police Department’s 2024 Annual Report, there were 7 rape incidents in 2024. That same report shows 113 thefts, 22 burglaries, and 26 vandalism cases, a total of 161 property crimes in just those three categories alone. That is a 23-to-1 ratio.
This does not mean those 7 cases don’t matter. But it does raise a fair question: does our public messaging accurately reflect what the City’s own data shows about public safety priorities? By the City’s own numbers, property crime represents the dominant statistical challenge.
The Chief and Mayors recent council work session presentation provided descriptions of workload and process, but it did not provide comparative data. We were not shown how St. Helens compares to Scappoose, to the the county, or to similar cities. We were not shown per-capita rates or trend lines. We were told about activity, but not given the context needed to understand whether what we’re experiencing is unusual or consistent with regional patterns.
Here’s what we know about capacity:
In October 2023, the City received approximately $340,000 in federal Department of Justice funding to build digital forensic capacity, including a mobile device examiner system and a digital forensic lab. Federal grants like this are awarded based on demonstrated workload, caseload volume, investigative demand, and projected need.
Once that capacity is built, it naturally generates increased activity. Departments accept more referrals, process more devices, and handle more cases, potentially including regional cases. This is normal and expected. But it means we need to distinguish between increased activity that reflects expanded capacity versus increased activity that reflects a local crime surge. Without comparative data, we cannot make that distinction.
Here’s what we know about budget:
The department is currently about $243,000 over budget on overtime. That is a significant variance that requires explanation.
Here’s what we don’t know and should:
There is a public records request pending that seeks information about how investigative time and resources are being used. The City has not fully produced those records.
Right now, nobody outside the department can verify:
How much time is spent on criminal versus non-criminal matters?
How much work is local versus external referrals?
Are these cases being resolved, or just accumulating workload?
How investigative time, including the Chief/Detective/Sergeant’s time, is actually allocated?
How much overtime is driven by cases from outside St. Helens?
That’s not transparency and accountability, its a blind spot.
These are the questions the public deserves answers to:
How does St. Helens compare to similar Oregon cities in per-capita crime rates?
What do the trends look like over the past five years?
How much of the digital forensics workload is local versus regional or referred cases?
How many cases are actually crimes versus preliminary reviews that never become criminal cases?
How much department time and taxpayer money has been spent on matters that are not criminal in nature?
Is overtime being driven by necessity, or by choices about scope and priorities?
What percentage of overtime is predictable vs emergency?
What is the total cost to the City, including PERS and benefits, of the overtime overage?
Bottom line:
If the city is being told “we need more money,” the public has the right to first ask: For what work? For whose cases? And for what legal purpose?
St. Helens and its residents come first. That’s not political. That’s literally the mission of a city government and its police department.
No funding request has yet been made, but presentations that emphasize workload volume without comparative data can set the stage for future budget requests to face less scrutiny.
The public deserves answers driven by facts and analysis, not by framing that may not reflect the complete picture. This is exactly what responsible oversight looks like.